IgG4/IgG RNA ratio does not accurately discriminate IgG4-related disease from pancreatobiliary cancer

Background & aims: IgG4-related disease (IgG4-RD) of the biliary tract and pancreas is often difficult to distinguish from pancreatobiliary cancer. The blood IgG4/IgG RNA ratio has been reported to discriminate IgG4-RD from primary sclerosing cholangitis/pancreatobiliary cancer with high accuracy. This study aimed to prospectively assess the diagnostic accuracy of the blood IgG4/IgG RNA ratio for distinguishing IgG4-RD from cancer in patients with a suspected pancreatobiliary malignancy.

Methods: In this prospective, single center, observational study, patients presenting at a specialized multidisciplinary, hepato-pancreato-biliary clinic with suspicion of pancreatobiliary malignancy were included. The IgG4/IgG RNA ratio (threshold 5.0%) was determined by quantitative PCR in addition to standard diagnostic procedures. Clinical, biochemical, radiological, and histo-/cytopathological findings were analyzed. For the diagnosis of IgG4-RD, the HISORt criteria were used as a reference standard. Malignancy was defined by the presence of neoplastic tissue at histo-/cytopathological examination.

Results: Overall, 213 consecutive patients (mean age 68 years) with a suspected pancreatobiliary malignancy were analyzed, of whom 3 patients were diagnosed with IgG4-RD and 178 patients were diagnosed with malignancy (165 patients with primary pancreatobiliary malignancy). The IgG4/IgG RNA ratio was true positive in 3 patients and false positive in 87 (40.8%) patients. In 123 (57.7%) patients the test was true negative. The sensitivity of blood IgG4/IgG RNA ratio was 100%, the specificity 58.6%, the positive predictive value 3.3%.

Conclusion: In the setting of a high a priori risk of malignancy, an elevated IgG4/IgG RNA ratio did not accurately discriminate pancreatobiliary cancer from IgG4-RD as illustrated by low specificity and concordant low positive predictive value. We advise against the use of this test to discriminate IgG4-RD from pancreatobiliary malignancies.

Lay summary: IgG4-related disease is a benign inflammatory multiorgan disease which predominantly affects the pancreas and biliary tree. Clinical symptoms, laboratory and imaging finding are often difficult to distinguish from pancreatic or biliary tract cancer. This prospective trial indicates that the recently proposed blood IgG4/IgG RNA ratio does not accurately distinguish benign IgG4-RD from malignant pancreatobiliary disease.

Keywords: AIP, auto-immune pancreatitis; AUC, area under the curve; CA 19.9, carbohydrate antigen 19.9; Cholangiocarcinoma; HPF, high power field; IRC, IgG4-related cholangitis; IgG4-RD, IgG4-related disease; IgG4-related cholangitis; Klatskin tumor; PSC, primary sclerosing cholangitis; ROC, receiver operating characteristics; pancreatic carcinoma; pancreatobiliary malignancy.